To understand a whole from a generating basis is quite cartesian (analytical maybe?) and perhaps atomist. It is indeed interesting how we "reconstruct" (built) the object in our own mind; it may be not be from the conservation of the "atoms" that generate the whole - since in any case, we as humans have different sets of knowledge that may not have been "transformed" or may not be amenable to "be transformed" into a different set of knowledge encompassing another individual thought. The second problem is the cartesianism within this approach: the parts are considered as ontologically prior to the whole. This is similar to the understanding that a topological space is first a set of elements, and second it comes with open sets formed from these elements (as opposed to locale where points come second.) These two issues require dialectics because of the contradictions (unification of opposites). And I believe that this is why conversations between human beings are important (for human beings at least). The *dialogical *process that underlies casual human conversation - especially in Mathematics - rehearses a game of dialectics (Thesis --> Anti-thesis --> synthesis -- > Thesis) that eventually brings to a final understanding (resp. resolution ) of a question (resp. problem). On Sun, Nov 15, 2026 at 10:43 AM Ando Razafindrakoto < arazafindrakoto@uwc.ac.za> wrote:
To understand a whole from a generating basis is quite cartesian (analytical maybe?) and perhaps atomist. It is indeed interesting how we "reconstruct" (built) the object in our own mind; it may be not be from the conservation of the "atoms" that generate the whole - since in any case, we as humans have different sets of knowledge that may not have been "transformed" or may not be amenable to "be transformed" into a different set of knowledge encompassing another individual thought. The second problem is the cartesianism within this approach: the parts are considered as ontologically prior to the whole. This is similar to the understanding that a topological space is first a set of elements, and second it comes with open sets formed from these elements (as opposed to locale where points come second.) These two issues require dialectics because of the contradictions (unification of opposites). And I believe that this is why conversations between human beings are important (for human beings at least). The *dialogical *process that underlies casual human conversation - especially in Mathematics - rehearses a game of dialectics (Thesis --> Anti-thesis --> synthesis -- > Thesis) that eventually brings to a final understanding (resp. resolution ) of a question (resp. problem).
On Sun, Nov 15, 2026 at 12:13 AM Vyacheslav Kalmykov via Categories < categories-list@categories.org.au> wrote:
On Understanding and Creativity
Modern sub-symbolic (neural network-based) AI has brought renewed focus to the concepts of "understanding" and "explaining" automated decision-making processes (e.g., the XAI initiative). Many have begun to ask: what, exactly, is understanding? Spinoza once remarked—to paraphrase from memory—that we understand something when we are able to reconstruct (build) it within our own minds. It occurred to me that this process of construction can be reduced to the principles of conservation.
Group theory and category theory characterize these conservation laws, which, in turn, boil down to constructing the object of our inquiry from a foundational set of elements—referred to as "generators" in group theory and "basic objects" in category theory. Both theories embody the same philosophical and scientific principle: to understand a whole is to identify its minimal generating basis and to describe the transformations that leave this basis invariant. Both approaches address a fundamental challenge: how to describe an infinite or colossally complex whole using a finite set of rules. Group theory achieves this through the internal symmetry of objects, while category theory does so through the symmetry of the relationships between them.
In the creative work of a mathematician, an aesthetic sense of beauty plays a significant role. And beauty, at its core, is symmetry. It seems likely that, in time, AI will also attain a formalized understanding of beauty—by way of group theory and category theory.
пт, 13 нояб. 2026 г. в 23:12, Posina Venkata Rayudu via Categories < categories-list@categories.org.au>:
With due apologies to the creative types, I remember reading "creativity", which made me hasten to share a more democratic reading of, than is likely to be the case with the aforementioned, creativity:
Nudging AI towards Truth https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-024-07930-y#article-comments
Since we are implicitly, if not explicitly, attending to the contrast:
procedural knowledge vs. declarative understanding
it seems to me that a test of understanding (in contrast to mere knowing) is, if not 'write in your own words' ( https://playinmath.wordpress.com/2023/02/08/history-and-philosophy-of-mathem... ), a more detailed instruction, a translation of the given conceptual repertoire into a desired one (of the audience), along with the corresponding presentations (words / sentences / displays) of the given and the desired repertoires of abstract generals. Going by Feynman's experience of failing to explain to a non-colleague at the MIT math dept., a proxy for understanding can be in terms of the category of map objects of functors between categories as abstract generals. Linguistic proficiency in a large number of languages (one of our prime ministers knew some 24 languages) is 'good for' communicating with diverse audience, while proficiency in concepts, their abstraction, interpretations, and laws of rational passage between concepts beyond all that logic that is familiar in going from a given sentence to a sentence as its conclusion (https://philpapers.org/rec/POSLOC) is 'good for' bringing into sharp focus the reality that is reflected in our thinking / experience. In closing, getting the matter that moves to move in directions desired by a thinking matter is beyond the reach of moving matter, and is what distinguishes matters that think: make falling matter fly :). Surely, there is something about AI---AI & I---conversation that's radiating tomorrow worth celebrating today (for those panic, there's petril ;) the deep history of thinking about things and about making things thought in the privacy of one's mind in conversation, a pleasant conversation (I have to tell all AIs to stop flattering for flattery and fame are not conducive to proper thinking which I value.), a fruitful conversation, the long-lost habit of the much-desired iron-manning of a meeting of matters---moving and thinking---material reflections of reality subsuming the architecture of understanding, a case study of intellect to document, a Bohr atom of understanding (instead of an abstract approach of, say, calculating the truth value triangle of a category of syllogisms <https://philpapers.org/rec/POSSAL>).
On Fri, Nov 13, 2026 at 1:55 AM Ando Razafindrakoto <arazafindrakoto@uwc.ac.za> wrote:
I read Marx's capital which starts with the accumulation of capital
Marx is not only Feuerbach. Marx is Feuerbach (materialism) and Hegel (dialectics).
On Thu, Nov 12, 2026 at 10:16 PM Dusko Pavlovic <duskgoo@gmail.com> wrote:
lawvere certainly didn't advise anyone to study philosophy through
quotations, authoritative or not. if you try reading marx, you will understand why many readers have many readings. marx of all people shouldn't be reduced to interpretations, knowing that so many people used
from the extraction of labour (including so-called "skilled labour", which is discussed briefly in Chapter 1 as well.) And that was the whole point of the initial citation. their interpretations to justify their crimes.
(incidentally, it is now echoing in my head that i wrote "10 theses
Ueber Feuerbach", didn't i? there were actually 11 theses. maybe my aging brain mixed up marx and moses 🤣 speaking of misinterpretations :)))
-- Ando Razafindrakoto Senior Lecturer Faculty of Natural Sciences Department of Mathematics and Applied Mathematics Landline: +27(0)21 959 3018 <+27%2021%20959%203018> Cellphone: +27(0)71 124 5014 <+27%2071%20124%205014> Homepage: https://sites.google.com/uwc.ac.za/ando/home www.uwc.ac.za
Disclaimer - This e-mail is subject to UWC policies and e-mail disclaimer published on our website at: https://www.uwc.ac.za/disclaimer
_______________________________________________ Categories mailing list -- categories-list@categories.org.au To unsubscribe send an email to categories-list-leave@categories.org.au
_______________________________________________ Categories mailing list -- categories-list@categories.org.au To unsubscribe send an email to categories-list-leave@categories.org.au
-- Ando Razafindrakoto Senior Lecturer Faculty of Natural Sciences Department of Mathematics and Applied Mathematics Landline: +27(0)21 959 3018 <+27%2021%20959%203018> Cellphone: +27(0)71 124 5014 <+27%2071%20124%205014> Homepage: https://sites.google.com/uwc.ac.za/ando/home www.uwc.ac.za <https://www.google.com/url?q=https://uwc.ac.za&source=gmail-html&ust=1655289284799000&usg=AOvVaw2MXM9-xWRLqwk62e6juGPq>
-- Ando Razafindrakoto Senior Lecturer Faculty of Natural Sciences Department of Mathematics and Applied Mathematics Landline: +27(0)21 959 3018 Cellphone: +27(0)71 124 5014 Homepage: https://sites.google.com/uwc.ac.za/ando/home www.uwc.ac.za <https://www.google.com/url?q=https://uwc.ac.za&source=gmail-html&ust=1655289284799000&usg=AOvVaw2MXM9-xWRLqwk62e6juGPq> -- Disclaimer - This e-mail is subject to UWC policies and e-mail disclaimer published on our website at: https://www.uwc.ac.za/disclaimer <https://www.uwc.ac.za/disclaimer>