Dear Mike Face-to-face research is very important. In the 1970s, Max Kelly and I convinced the Australian Research Council and our universities that face-to-face contact to mathematics was as important as a visit to a telescope for an astronomer or a visit to some immovable rock by a geologist. We were able to obtain some funding for our long trips from Australia and for mathematical visitors to Australia. However, in those no-email days we also had a superb postal system. An aerogramme posted in a suburb of Sydney on Monday morning would arrive in my mailbox at U Illinois (Champaign-Urbana) on Wednesday. A lot of my work with Day, Kelly, Freyd and others was done that way. We really thought before we wrote since there was no erasing, not much space, and a week's turn around time. Then there were the long phone calls. These were expensive for international (trunk) calls. One time, talking to Bob Walters for quite awhile, we were unaware that we had a crossed line. A young person listening in recognised that all this Yoneda business was mathematics. They broke in to our conversation saying: "x equals minus b plus or minus the square root of b squared minus four a c all over two a" then slammed their phone down. For me, somehow, the phone worked better than zoom meetings do now; however, zoom is better than nothing. I think the main, and maybe terrifying, things about AI are its speed and arrogance. In high school, we had a little book of tables including base 10 logarithms. No need to know how to multiply anymore! BUT, you still had to have a feeling for numbers to tell when you came up with something ridiculous. In practical statistics classes as an undergrad, we had big heavy machines where you turned the handle 10 times to multiply by 10. They were soon replaced by electricity powered versions. Then there were pocket calculators. Engineers didn't need to do mathematics anymore, people said. Computers. Personal computers. Workstations. And so on. Maybe quantum computers. We can certainly keep doing the old stuff faster. No doubt AI will be used to justify sacking workers of all kinds, not just mathematicians. Will that help make a better world? Time to stop rambling. Ross On 11 Nov 2026, at 7:21 am, Michael Barr, Prof. via Categories <categories-list@categories.org.au> wrote: I've given some thought to this and I just don't see what AI is going to train on. For all my career, I have counted on face to face meeting with people. I wanted to talk to them and the conversations were never recorded. I remember running accidentally into Jon Beck in the 42nd Street Times Square subway station during the winter break 1964-65 and he started telling my about acyclic models. He had just visited Harry Appelgate who had written his PhD on the categorification of that concept. Jon and I eventually modified it further and we were off. We had spent the entire fall semester trying to relate Eilenberg-Mac Lane group cohomology to the free group triple and this solved it instantly. For about 15 years, John Kennison would spend 6 weeks in Montreal every spring and he and Bob Raphael and I would meet for 4 or 5 hours every day and talk, often going to the board to explain, but mainly just talking. Practically every year we wrote a joint paper as a result. This ended with the pandemic and John canceled in 2020. We have not met since. We tried zooming together but that has not worked. We enjoy the conversations but no mathematics results. As far as I am concerned, nothing can replace these face to face sessions and I cannot see training AI on that. Michael