Re: Achieving "neither P nor not P"

Vaughan Pratt wrote:

Fred, I don't believe you can reliably conflate the propositions "change is not good" and "not(change is good)".

Careful, Vaughan, could you simply be conflating one of those, and not the other, with "change is bad"? I can't do that, myself.

In fact I believe you can't reliably conflate them.

Well, that belief's a good reason for you not to "believe you can", but I don't seem to share that belief yet :-) . Or perhaps, once the novelty of the example wears off, I'll come to realize it limps as badly as the earlier examples adduced in that Bangalore piece. Cheers, -- Fred [For admin and other information see: http://www.mta.ca/~cat-dist/ ]