Dear Mike, It's nice to hear from you! I hope you are well. Here, in Switzerland, all is well, as we are relatively protected from _some_ of the world's turmoil - and the scenery remains beautiful! :-) I am writing to say I really appreciated your examples: they put forth convincing, concrete and therefore helpful, examples of what others have said more theoretically. Thank you for enriching the discussion! Best and sincere regards, Gavin On Mon, Nov 9, 2026, at 02:19, Michael Barr, Prof. via Categories wrote:
While this is not about categories specifically I have some comments I would like to make public and this would seem to be my outlet. So please bear with me.
The main thing I want to say about math and AI is that AI appears to be excellent at answering questions, but I see no evidence that it is capable of asking them. And the latter, I feel, is the main thing a research mathematician contributes to the advancement of mathematics. I am going to illustrate this point by two examples from my own career.
I spent a month in Fribourg in 1997 and during that month, Heinrich Kleisli and I wrote a paper called Topological Balls. The way this paper came about was that every day Heinrich and I would meet in his office and discuss the topic and he would ask a question. I would go back to the apartment I was occupying and answer his question. The next day I would explain my answer and we would have a further discussion and he would raise a new question. And I would answer that in the even and so on and so on till at the end of my stay we had a paper. In my opinion, Heinrich contributed more to it than I did. No questions, no paper.
During the year 1969-70, my second at McGill, I was working on regular and exact categories, quite consciously trying to adapt the ideas of abelian categories to non-additive ones. After finding what still seem like the correct definitions, I wanted to adapt theorem that a small abelian category has a faithful functor to Ab. By that time Saul Lubkin's proof and a quite different one from Peter Freyd were known. There was also Barry Mitchell's full embedding into a category of modules over a ring. I succeeded in adapting Lubkin's proof to show that a small regular category had a faithful functor to Set, provided that the terminal object had no proper subobject, except possibly an empty object, meaning one that was not the codomain of any map other its own identity (or any other isomorphism to be sure). In the meantime Kleisli had invited me to spend the year 1970-71 in Fribourg and had gotten a grant from the Swiss Research Council to do so.
So, I took an unpaid leave and headed to Fribourg, On the way there, I stopped in Philly to visit my family and looked in on Peter Freyd at Penn. I explained what I had done and Peter asked me whether it was possible to get a full embedding theorem out of the method by replacing Set by M-Set for a suitable monoid M (which turned out to be the monoid of endomorphisms of the original embedding). To my surprise, it was! And not particularly hard to prove. That means that Lubkin could have had a full embedding theorem too, had he realized. Anyway, on to Fribourg where I showed Heinrich what I had done and he asked whether it would be possible to drop the condition on subobjects of 1 and replace M-Set by a category of the form Set^C for some small category C. It was! And not too hard either. The point was that, unlike me, he thought of a monoid as a small category.
So two questions, one from Peter and one from Heinrich, had elevated what was probably a minor result to one of the major accomplishments of my career. And this is why I think that questions are more important than answers.
Michael
_______________________________________________ Categories mailing list -- categories-list@categories.org.au To unsubscribe send an email to categories-list-leave@categories.org.au