What are the standard references for weighted limits and colimits in enriched categories? I know about Borceux, volume 2, chapter 6, but that does not go far enough. More precisely, I want to know how functorial the weighted colimit is in the weight. Given a V-natural transformation F --> F', presumably I get some kind of map from colim_F G to colim_F' G (or the other way around). I would like a reference for this fact and related functoriality facts. Presumably the weighted colimit is a bifunctor in the weight and the functor one is taking the colimit of, and presumably this bifunctor has various good properties. Has anybody ever written these down? Thanks in advance for any help you can give me. Mark Hovey
Mark Hovey writes:
What are the standard references for weighted limits and colimits in enriched categories? I know about Borceux, volume 2, chapter 6, but that does not go far enough.
Have a look at Chapter 3 of Max Kelly's book ``The basic concepts of enriched category theory'', LMS lecture note series 64.
More precisely, I want to know how functorial the weighted colimit is in the weight. Given a V-natural transformation F --> F', presumably I get some kind of map from colim_F G to colim_F' G (or the other way around). I would like a reference for this fact and related functoriality facts.
Yes, it is functorial in F, in the way that you have written above.
Presumably the weighted colimit is a bifunctor in the weight and the functor one is taking the colimit of, and presumably this bifunctor has various good properties. Has anybody ever written these down?
Once again, yes. There's quite a lot in the reference above. Kelly writes F*G for what you have called colim_F G, and {F,G} for what you would presumably call lim_F G. He develops results based on the intuition that * is a kind of tensor product, and {-,-} a kind of internal hom, and proves results like the associativity of * and {F*G,H}={F,{G,H}}. Of course this sounds a bit odd, because the F and the G live in different categories, but you can actually make sense of these things. There is even an isomorphism F*G=G*F in the case of colimits in V itself. There's another approach, which probably goes back to Street and Walters, Yoneda structures on 2-categories, J. Algebra 50:350-379, 1978 and has been developed by Street and many others since. In this approach you define a bicategory, often called V-Prof or V-Mod, in which an object is a V-category, and a morphism from A to B, often written A-|->B is a V-functor from A to [B^op,V], and a 2-cell is a natural transformation. (This direction of the 1-cells and 2-cells in this definition is not universally adopted.) Then composition is given by colimit, in the sense that if f:A-|->B and g:B-|->C, then gf:A-|->C is defined by gf(a,c)=g(-,c)*f(a,-). Then associativity (up to isomorphism) of composition in this bicategory is the associaitivity of * referred to above. In fact this bicategory is closed, in the sense that composition has an adjoint, constructed using {-,-}. Steve Lack.
In his letter below, Mark Harvey asks about the functoriality of the weighted colimit F*G where we are dealing with V-categories and say F: K --> V and G: K --> A. The matter is dealt with at length in my book ["Basic Concepts of Enriched Category Theory", London Math Soc. Lecture Notes Series 64, Cambridge University Press, 1982.]. (The book uses the older terminology "indexed limit" for "weighted limit" and so on. See Chapter 3, and the work in Chapter 4 on final and initial weights. Max Kelly. _______________ Subject: categories: Weighted limits Date: 05 Nov 2001 13:23:24 -0500 From: Mark Hovey <hovey@picard.math.wesleyan.edu> To: categories@mta.ca Mark Hovey wrote:
What are the standard references for weighted limits and colimits in enriched categories? I know about Borceux, volume 2, chapter 6, but that does not go far enough.
More precisely, I want to know how functorial the weighted colimit is in the weight. Given a V-natural transformation F --> F', presumably I get some kind of map from colim_F G to colim_F' G (or the other way around). I would like a reference for this fact and related functoriality facts.
Presumably the weighted colimit is a bifunctor in the weight and the functor one is taking the colimit of, and presumably this bifunctor has various good properties. Has anybody ever written these down?
Thanks in advance for any help you can give me. Mark Hovey
Perhaps a useful reference on weighted (there called indexed) limits is Chapter 3 of Basic Concepts of Enriched Category Theory by Max Kelly, containing your desired result and much more. BTW, Peter Johnstone wrote a rather nice (and amusing) review of BCECT in the Bulletin of the London Mathematical Society, supplementing the helpful, accurate, but not very farseeing (in terms of potential applications for ECs) BAMS review by Gray and Linton's short antidote to Gray in MR. Regards, Keith Harbaugh _________________________________________________________________ Get your FREE download of MSN Explorer at http://explorer.msn.com/intl.asp
participants (4)
-
Keith Harbaugh -
Mark Hovey -
Max Kelly -
Steve Lack