Do there exist nontrivial locally bounded geometric morphisms and/or locally (pre)sheaf toposes?
Recently I posted this question https://mathoverflow.net/q/277582/41291 to mathoverflow and now it occurred to me that most likely I can get a quick answer here. Are there geometric morphisms f: YY -> XX which are (1) locally but not globally bounded, or (2) locally but not globally presheaf, or (3) as in (2) and bounded? In more detail, I mean this: there must be an object X in XX with global support (X->1 epic) such that the pullback f/X: YY/f^*(X) -> XX/X is (1) bounded, while f is not bounded, or (2) equivalent over XX/X to the topos (XX/X)^{CC^op} of internal presheaves on some internal category CC of XX/X, while YY is not equivalent to any such over XX, or (3) same as (2) and in addition f bounded. Can any of these happen? Hoping, Mamuka [For admin and other information see: http://www.mta.ca/~cat-dist/ ]
The answer to Mamuka's question (1) is no. Observe first that YY/f^*(X) is bounded over XX/X iff it's bounded over XX, since XX/X --> XX is bounded. And one has: Proposition: If Y has global support in YY and G is a bound for YY/Y over XX, then \Sigma_Y(G) is a bound for YY over XX. Proof: By assumption, any object B of YY/Y is a subquotient of some object G \times Y^*f^*(I), with I an object of XX. But the Frobenius reciprocity condition \Sigma_Y(G\times Y^*f^*(I)) \cong \Sigma_Y(G) \times f^*(I) holds, so \Sigma_Y(B) is a subquotient of \Sigma_Y(G)\times f^*(I). Finally, since Y has global support, any object A of XX is a quotient of \Sigma_Y(Y^*(A)) \cong A \times Y. I have no thoughts at present about question (2). Peter Johnstone On Mon, 31 Jul 2017, Mamuka Jibladze wrote:
Recently I posted this question
https://mathoverflow.net/q/277582/41291
to mathoverflow and now it occurred to me that most likely I can get a quick answer here.
Are there geometric morphisms f: YY -> XX which are
(1) locally but not globally bounded, or (2) locally but not globally presheaf, or (3) as in (2) and bounded?
In more detail, I mean this: there must be an object X in XX with global support (X->1 epic) such that the pullback f/X: YY/f^*(X) -> XX/X is
(1) bounded, while f is not bounded, or (2) equivalent over XX/X to the topos (XX/X)^{CC^op} of internal presheaves on some internal category CC of XX/X, while YY is not equivalent to any such over XX, or (3) same as (2) and in addition f bounded.
Can any of these happen?
Hoping, Mamuka
[For admin and other information see: http://www.mta.ca/~cat-dist/ ]
participants (2)
-
Mamuka Jibladze -
Peter Johnstone